
Thighs braised down slowly with tomatoes and mushrooms until the sauce goes glossy.
Swaps that keep this dish what it is. The prices on this page are for the recipe as written.
Vegetarian
Cannellini Bean Cacciatore
Skip browning the protein; add the drained beans with the tinned tomatoes and simmer uncovered for 25 to 30 minutes instead of 75, until the sauce is glossy.
Vegan
Cannellini Bean Cacciatore
Skip browning the protein; add the drained beans with the tinned tomatoes and simmer uncovered for 25 to 30 minutes instead of 75, until the sauce is glossy.
Gluten-free
Cook the polenta to the packet instructions in the last 10 minutes and serve the cacciatore spooned over it.
Swaps are suggestions — check labels if you are cooking for an allergy.
List price at each shop
no items missing · $21.47 of food
$41.82
49% spare
no items missing · $24.32 of food · $2.85 more
$50.40
52% spare
no items missing · $24.91 of food · $3.44 more
$40.35
38% spare
$5.37a serve
$5.37 a serve, cheapest at Aldi
About $21.47 of ingredients used for 4 serves.
$38.70 across 3 shops · all 10 items priced · $2.65 more for bigger packs, 48% spare for later
$21.47
no items missing
you'll pay $41.82 · 49% of it spare
$24.32
no items missing · $2.85 more
you'll pay $50.40 · 52% of it spare
$24.91
no items missing · $3.44 more
you'll pay $40.35 · 38% of it spare
Chicken thigh fillets
$13.29/kg
need 800 gBroad Oak Farms approx. 1.16 kg$13.29closest match
Aldi$13.29/kg$13.29·
Coles$14.50/kg$15.95·
Woolworths$14.50/kg$26.10
Tinned chopped tomatoes
$2.38/kg
need 800 g2 × Remano Italian Diced Tomatoes 400 g$0.95closest match
Aldi$2.38/kg$0.95·
Woolworths$2.38/kg$0.95·
Coles$2.38/kg$0.95
Garlic
$29.99/kg
need 20 gNo Brand Garlic approx. 60 g$1.80
Aldi$29.99/kg$1.80·
Woolworths~$31.33/kg$1.88·
Coles$33.00/kg$1.98
Tomato paste
$0.28/100g
need 50 gCucina Tomato Paste 500 g$1.39closest match
Aldi$0.28/100g$1.39·
Woolworths$0.56/100g$0.95·
Coles$0.71/100g$1.00
Crusty bread loaf
$0.37/100g
need 1 itemBillie's Bakehouse White Loaf 800g$2.99closest match 1 pack assumed, quantity unknown (sold by weight)
Aldi$0.37/100g$2.99·
Woolworths$0.60/100g$3.60·
Coles$0.57/100g$4.00
Olive oil
$0.88/100ml
need 30 mlThe Olive Tree Olive Oil 1 L$8.79closest match
Aldi$0.88/100ml$8.79·
Woolworths$2.80/100ml$7.00·
Coles$2.80/100ml$7.00

Brown onion
~$3.32/kg
need 200 g2 × Onion Brown each 189.76 g$0.63
Woolworths~$3.32/kg$0.63·
Coles$4.20/kg$0.84·
Aldi$3.49/kg$0.63

Dried oregano
$1.07/10g
need 2 gSpencers Oregano 15 g$1.60closest match
Woolworths$1.07/10g$1.60·
Coles$2.00/10g$2.00·
Aldi$1.99/10g$2.79

Mushrooms
$12.50/kg
need 250 gColes Flat Mushrooms Loose approx. 350 g$4.38closest match
Coles$12.50/kg$4.38·
Woolworths$12.50/kg$4.38·
Aldi$15.97/kg$5.99

Capsicum
$5.90/kg
need 200 gColes Red Capsicum Loose approx. 220 g$1.30real special
Coles$5.90/kg$1.30·
Aldi$6.49/kg$1.62·
Woolworths~$7.36/kg$1.73